+44 (0)7815 107231 info@digitalworkresearch.com

Articles

Insights on digital skills and well-being

Is your organisation’s digital workplace causing technostress?

by | Jan 10, 2019 | Digital well-being, Digital workplace

In a nutshell? Despite its many benefits, the digital workplace can also cause unintended negative consequences for workers, such as technostress and information overload. These effects can be mitigated both by how the digital workplace is designed and delivered, and by helping people upskill. Cultivating a mindful approach to using technology can play a role in the latter.

The digital workplace has become a pervasive part of most of our working lives. Its benefits, including unprecedented levels of connectedness and productivity, are increasingly well understood and organisations are investing significant sums in digital workplace programmes.

However, the same technology that is providing organisations and individuals with so much empowerment and opportunity also comes with a ‘dark side’ that includes a body of unintended negative consequences. A couple of years ago, Finnish researchers Henri Pirkkalainen and Markus Salo reviewed the research in this area and identified four ‘dark side’ phenomena connected with use of technology in the workplace: technostress, information overload, IT ‘addiction’ and IT anxiety. These phenomena threaten to make individuals’ relationship with the digital workplace a toxic one that can have damaging consequences both for individual well-being and organisational outcomes.

Let’s take a look at them more closely:

Technostress

The term ‘technostress’ was coined by author Craig Brod in the early eighties. He defined it as ‘a modern disease of adaptation caused by an inability to cope with new computer technologies in a healthy manner’. A decade later Larry Rosen – an expert in the psychology of technology – and colleagues added another definition, saying that technostress encompasses ‘any negative impact on attitudes, thoughts, behaviours or psychology caused directly or indirectly by technology’. In the workplace, technostress can arise due to a range of technological impacts such as the speed of changes, constant connectivity, anxiety about one’s capabilities and skills to use it, and an overload of information and inputs. It can lead to fatigue, difficulties in paying attention, frustration, loss of motivation, lower work satisfaction and burnout.

Information overload

Both inside and outside of the workplace, this is a phenomenon most of us experience to some degree as the sheer quantity of information available to us digitally can outstrip our ability to cognitively process it. Cenfetelli and Schwarz (2011) define it as an individual state in which ‘too much information is provided beyond the user’s needs resulting in perceptions of being overwhelmed’. A range of factors can contribute to information overload during the working day, from overflowing inboxes and interruptions via instant messaging, to information repositories with swathes of content to dig through and low signal-to-noise ratio. It can negatively impact on a range of factors including individuals’ ability to pay attention, make optimal decisions, and be productive or produce novel ideas in their work, as well as general well-being and quality of life. Some research has shown that it is a strong predictor of both technostress and turnover.

IT ‘addiction’

Although technology addiction is not yet formally recognised as a mental disorder (hence the quote marks around ‘addiction’), a growing body of research does suggest that technology addictions can exhibit similar characteristics to substance addictions. They can also have similar negative impacts, for instance, in a work context, causing work-family conflict and compromising quality of life as well as work attitudes and behaviours. One definition of this kind of addiction is: ‘a users’ psychological state of maladaptive dependency on IT use that is manifested through the obsessive-compulsive pattern of IT-seeking and IT-use behaviours that take place at the expense of other important activities.’ (Xu et al. 2012). While many digital workplaces may not look all that addictive, compared to say gaming or social media technologies, the ability to connect 24/7 can fuel work addiction, leading to negative impacts on both work quality and impinging on non-work relationships, commitments and interests.

IT anxiety

IT or computer anxiety was a term coined in the sixties to describe the trauma of employees undergoing computerisation in their company (Masters 1967). You’d hope things have got a little better in the era of the modern digital workplace, however this phenomena is still quite prevalent. It’s characterised by feelings of worry and apprehension along with physical tension relating to one’s current or future use of computers, for instance, the fear of making mistakes or losing data. It can also lead to technostress. At its most extreme, IT anxiety can become ‘technophobia’ which involves resistance to using technology at all. Unsurprisingly it can have a negative impact on adoption and use of IT in the workplace.

The full impact of these ‘dark side’ phenomena on individual and organisational outcomes is not yet fully understood. If we take just technostress, which is probably the most extensively studied so far, and note that it is considered an important contributor to overall workplace stress – this gives us an indicator. The American Psychological Association has estimated the cost of workplace stress to US businesses at $300 billion a year (2010); while The Mindfulness All Party Parliamentary Group has estimated the cost to UK industry at £70-100 billion per year (2015). This gives us pause for thought in considering the importance of digital workplace programmes that focus relentlessly on how people in the organisation work and what they need.

Mitigating factors

We can take several approaches to helping workers mitigate these ‘dark side’ phenomena:

How we design and deliver the digital workplace

  • Involve people at all stages of new digital workplace technologies – research has shown that enabling people to participate at all phases of planning, developing and implementing new tools and systems (for instance, providing feedback on functionality or learning about it in advance) can help reduce negative psychological impacts for workers.
  • Incorporate design principles that reduce stress – certain UX design principles can help to mitigate stressors, for instance, helping us control interruptions, reducing the sense of overload, using a more human tone in messages, and providing feedback that helps build confidence in using the system.
  • Provide ongoing support and guidance– support needs to be readily available via a range of mechanisms and channels on an ongoing basis for people to feel more secure and comfortable and reduce stress associated with tools and systems.

Helping people become skillful at working in the digital workplace

  • Help people raise their level of digital literacy – this is about enabling workers to gain a well-rounded set of skills to use digital workplace technology (something I cover in depth in my report on this topic). In particular, helping people share strategies for working with technology and learning from each other can be important in shielding individuals from negative effects. It’s very much about facilitating the discovery of their own coping mechanisms and personal approaches to technology, as well as facilitating the sharing of this knowledge among the workforce.
  • Introduce mindfulness principles to technology use – another potential approach to developing a healthy relationship with workplace technology is mindfulness. As a mindfulness practitioner and newly qualified teacher, I find the potential of applying the qualities of purposeful attention and broad awareness that we cultivate in mindfulness practice to our use of technology. There’s now a strong evidence base for mindfulness as an intervention to reduce workplace stress. In the technology domain, less work has been done as yet, although there is some early research that suggests that fostering mindfulness skills among employees can positively influence their perceptions of technology and intention to use it as well as mitigating negative consequences from information overload and technostress. I while back I wrote about ‘7 approaches to mindful technology use‘ that may be helpful here.

What are your own experiences of the four ‘dark side’ phenomena in the workplace? How are you working to mitigate them in your workplace?

I’ll be presenting on both digital literacy and mindful use of technology at the upcoming Intrateam Copenhagen Conference on 26-28 February. It would be great to see you there! You can use the discount code ElizabethMarsh25 for 25% off all EUR tickets at the checkout.

A selection of papers I’ve looked at in connection with this topic:

  • Galluch, P. S., Grover, V., and Thatcher, J. B. (2015) ‘Interrupting the workplace: Examining stressors in an information technology context’. Journal of the Association for Information Systems16(1), 1-47.
  • Ioannou, A., Papazafeiropoulou, A. and Spanaki, K. (2018). ‘The Mindfulness Concept in Information Systems (IS) Literature: A Review’. 26thEuropean Conference on Information Systems (ECIS)
  • Moraveji, N., & Soesanto, C. (2012). ‘Towards stress-less user interfaces: 10 design heuristics based on the psychophysiology of stress’. In CHI’12 extended abstracts on Human factors in computing systems (pp. 1643-1648). ACM.
  • Pirkkalainen, H., and Salo, M. (2016) ‘Two decades of the dark side in the information systems basket: Suggesting five areas for future research’. In ECIS 2016: Proceedings of the 24th European Conference on Information Systems, Tel Aviv, Israel, June 9-11, 2014. European Conference on Information Systems
  • Ragu-Nathan, T. S., Tarafdar, M., Ragu-Nathan, B. S., and Tu, Q. (2008) ‘The consequences of technostress for end users in organizations: Conceptual development and empirical validation’. Information Systems Research19(4), 417-433
  • Salanova, M., Llorens, S., and Cifre, E. (2013) ‘The dark side of technologies: Technostress among users of information and communication technologies’. International Journal of Psychology48(3), 422-436

Originally published on Linked In.

Get in touch to chat about any of our services