As we collectively shift to hybrid ways of working across digital and physical workplaces post pandemic, organisations need to think twice about the introduction of technologies to monitor staff. While they may have their place in certain scenarios, if implemented sensitively, they can have significant negative impacts for employee well-being. The implication can also be that management practices are poor – however, no digital workplace technology can fix bad management or a lack of trust in employees.
There was a popular meme on social media in the last year asking who or what is driving the digital transformation of the organisation. Anticipated answers of the CEO or CTO are passed over in favour of Covid. The digitalisation of work is a trajectory that organisations have been on for decades, catalysed by increasingly powerful and ubiquitous communication technologies, but the pandemic has dramatically accelerated the shift towards new, digital ways of working.
As early as April 2020, when organisations were still scrabbling to ensure that the workforce was equipped with the needed devices, applications and skills to work remotely, Gartner reported that nearly three quarters of them expected to permanently shift some employees to this way of working[i]. It’s a move that has been well received by many, with Global Workplace Analytics reporting that 77% of workers want to continue working in this way once the pandemic is over[ii].
The potential for better outcomes for both individuals and organisations due to digital working, such as increased productivity and flexibility, are widely understood. A group of researchers (e.g. Monideepa Tarafdar, Jean-François Stich, Marisa Salanova) also point out the dangers or ‘dark sides’ of our increasing engagement with work via the digital workplace, highlighting negative outcomes such as technostress, information overload, addiction and computer anxiety. It’s the subject of my doctoral research at the University of Nottingham where I’ve recently completed a literature review of such ‘dark side’ effects.
As staff migrated from the office to their homes – extending work into the back bedroom or onto the kitchen table – one trend that has been a concern was the uptick in the use of technologies to monitor workers. It’s a topic that hit the headlines in a CNBC news item covering the increase in recent months in surveillance of employees via monitoring tools like Prodoscore or Transparent Business, both of which have reportedly seen a large spike in interest and users[iii]. These tools track and record employee activities on the computer (e.g. keystrokes made, e-mails sent and received, applications used) as well as their location and presence.
The item features a lived example of the potential negative effects of surveillance from a nurse at a major US health company whose experience of a switch to employee monitoring and the associated micro-management of her work was so stressful that she quit her job. A number of commentators in the news item argue strongly against the claimed benefits of such tools to deliver better productivity and engagement, suggesting that they can be counterproductive, leading to decreased morale and increased burnout among staff. Darren Murph, Head of Remote at Github says: ‘Humans are not robots, we’re empathetic beings and especially in a remote setting the fabric of that, the culture of that is really important for morale to stay high and for people to feel connected as a team and not just another cog in the wheel.’
Jamie Woodcock, Senior Lecturer in Work and Organisations at the Open University further points out that the evidence from research does not support the use of employee monitoring. Although he doesn’t go into detail, a rigorous review of 85 studies of electronic monitoring by occupational health and safety researcher Nils Backhaus in 2019 does indeed suggest that negative outcomes are often the result of employee monitoring technologies[iv]. Backhaus points out both the potential positives (e.g. occupational safety and care) and negatives (e.g. control and coercion by mangers) that can flow from the use of employee monitoring. However, his review finds that it is largely associated with the negative effects which include higher stress and strain and lower job motivation and satisfaction, although these can be mitigated to some extent by approaches that improve the transparency of such systems and the way in which they are introduced.
While some researchers suggest approaches to minimise the risks of electronic monitoring technologies, others question its fundamental value and presence inside our workplaces. This echoes a perspective in the CNBC coverage that suggests that EPM use is simply an extension of poor management techniques and lack of trust in employees. In a seminal paper on how technology is changing work, Cascio and Montealegre (2016) point out how such technology may be viewed by employees as inhibiting their autonomy and lead to stress and a sense of oppression at work[v].
As we enter an era in which digital working is now a fixture in the working life of many people, the technologies and approaches used to keep organisations productive need careful consideration in order to also protect the well-being of their employees. Grafting new technologies onto old, failed management practices seems unlikely to deliver benefits for individuals or organisations.
What are your experiences of working and managing remotely during the pandemic and since? Have employee monitoring systems been a part of your ‘new normal’ and, if so, what has been the impact?
[i] https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2020-04-03-gartner-cfo-surey-reveals-74-percent-of-organizations-to-shift-some-employees-to-remote-work-permanently2
[ii] https://globalworkplaceanalytics.com/global-work-from-home-experience-survey
[iii] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/06/17/employee-surveillance-software-is-seeing-a-spike-as-workers-stay-home.html?
[iv] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8700354
[v] https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2016-34486-014
Originally published on Linked In.
