A range of recent studies have highlighted an alarming digital skills gap in organisations around the world. It’s hindering digital workplace progress and overall digital transformation as well as impacting on key measures like productivity and performance. (For more on this, see my previous post on the challenge facing organisations).
Yet surely as ‘digital natives’ progressively enter the workforce, this digital skills gap will close and all will be well?
Unfortunately, it’s not quite that straightforward.
Evidence suggests that fostering the digital literacy required in the digital workplace takes more than just consuming digital media and connecting with friends on social networks via a smartphone. Being digitally native, it seems, doesn’t necessarily mean being digital workplace ready. For instance:
- Only 50% of students agree that their course prepares them well for the digital workplace (JISC 2017) – and, worryingly, in JISC’s 2018 survey this figure went down to 41%.
- 47% of senior decision makers do not believe that younger workers know how to use digital skills for work purposes (Capgemini UK 2016).
- Although younger people may have better technical skills, they may perform less well on critical thinking skills (Eshet-Alkalai & Chajut 2011).
- 45% of students are only rudimentary users of digital (Kennedy et al. 2010).
- 60% of students never use digital equipment in their classroom (European Commission 2013).
It’s an issue I touch on in my report ‘The Digital Workplace Skills Framework: Ensuring the workforce is ready to work digitally’. I got to thinking about it more last week as I had the chance to run a workshop on this topic for some MSc Business students at Warwick University.
After introducing the students to the framework, I got them to complete a high-level self-assessment to measure their own digital workplace skills and identify areas for improvement. It’s far from the in-depth digital diagnostic needed to really assess digital workplace skills, but it provided a heuristic to get them thinking about their own skills.
Walking around and talking to the students, I don’t think I saw any self-assessment sheets without at least some improvement areas. These smart and digitally confident young people, sporting a range of devices in the lecture hall, clearly felt that they had some work to do in order to ensure that they are digitally ready for the workplaces they’ll be joining very soon.
Areas for further development, as identified by the students included:
- Optimising one’s digital environment (in a work or educational context) in order to be more productive, rather than just operating using the basic or default set-up.
- Managing cognitive overload in context of a whole range of potentially distracting real-time inputs.
- Communicating confidently and fluently across a range of different tools and channels, including switching between external and internal social networks.
- Generating and sharing ideas with confidence in the digital workplace.
It was a good reminder that although younger workers may have a higher level of comfort with and enthusiasm for technology, like the rest of the workforce they are likely to need help in order to get the most out of the digital workplace.
The terms ‘digital native’ and ‘digital immigrant’, introduced by educator Marc Prensky in 2001, are generally thought to oversimplify the nature of digital abilities and interactions across different generations. For instance, Dr Mark Bullen points out that research does not support Prensky’s account and that it is much too simplistic to explain the nuances in how different generations approach and use technology and their related skills and competences.
Nevertheless, the ‘digital native’ idea is now firmly planted in our wider discourse about the digital age, thereby influencing what organisations believe about younger people entering the workplace. This could potentially lead to misdirected – or simply missing – digital skills initiatives and programmes that help them and other workers gain competence with digital workplace tools.
For organisations looking to take a more considered and effective approach, they first need to understand the ‘Digital IQ’ of the organisation by assessing the skills of the current workforce. The Digital Workplace Skills Framework is designed with exactly this approach in mind – it provides a broad foundation on which to build out a digital diagnostic. Where general digital literacy models and frameworks don’t take account of the specific context of the workplace, it applies a digital workplace lens to the skills required by the modern workforce.
Download the framework to get started with understanding the digital skills challenge and what to do about it, or contact me if you want to get help applying it in your organisation.
What’s your view on the ‘digital natives’ debate – helpful or a hindrance for organisations trying to suss out the best approach to digitally upskill the workforce?
Originally published on Linked In.
