Why should organisations invest valuable resources into raising the ‘digital IQ’ of its workforce? A raft of high-profile industry studies suggest that there’s a strong case for doing so, and now new academic research is adding fresh evidence to the case.
I’m very pleased that my research study ‘Understanding the effect of digital literacy on employees’ digital workplace continuance intentions and individual performance’ (snappy title, I know) has just been published in the peer reviewed journal, the International Journal of Digital Literacy and Digital Competence.
Here’s the abstract for the article: While a growing body of literature suggests that employees’ digital skills are important to enable both individuals and organisations to make the most of the digital workplace, empirical understanding of their effect on technology adoption and performance is currently limited. Drawing on prior models of technology acceptance and continuance, the present study investigated the effect of digital literacy on behavioural intention to continue using the digital workplace and, ultimately, on individual performance. Linear regression was used to analyse the conceptual model using survey data from 142 employees of a major UK charitable organisation. Results partially supported the model, demonstrating that employees’ digital skills effect continuance intentions and individual performance via their perceptions of ease of use. The findings suggest an important role for digital literacy, both as an antecedent to the more general determinants of technology adoption, and in organisational interventions designed to encourage digital workplace adoption.
Why this study?
There were a number of reasons that I undertook this study (which was part of a MSc Psychology):
- Although information systems is a mature academic research stream, there are as yet relatively few studies that focus on the digital workplace as an integrated concept. I felt it important, as someone who works in this industry, to bolster this emergent research stream that will, over time, hopefully provide useful insights and evidence to practitioners.
- While a great deal of research has been conducted on digital literacy, this is almost always within an educational rather than workplace context. I therefore wanted to add to our understanding of digital skills in this sphere of life.
- Furthermore, despite indications that digital literacy is important for users to adopt and use technologies as intended, there is very little empirical understanding as yet of its effect on technology adoption and individual performance.
I tend to say of this study “it’s not rocket science”. Afterall, it seems logical that digital skills would impact on technology acceptance behaviours. However, I do believe it makes a small but significant contribution in the areas outlined above and, if we want to take an increasingly evidence-based approach to the digital workplace, that’s important.
How I approached it
To test the effect of digital literacy on digital workplace acceptance and individual performance, I developed a new conceptual model (see below), drawing on well-established models and measures in the fields of technology acceptance and digital literacy. I talk about “continuance” a lot in the study and this is because the study related to ongoing use of an existing set of digital tools.
This was a quantitative study that I was thrilled to conduct in a major UK charitable organisation (the people I was working with there were as excited about what we would find as I was!). Just over 140 employees responded to the survey. Participants, surveyed anonymously, gave self-report data on their views of their own digital literacy as well as attitudes and behavioural intentions towards the digital workplace and perceived performance when using it. Immersing myself in the statistics, I analysed the data using linear regression in order to explore the paths in the model.
Naturally the study had its limitations, which I explore in depth in the paper. For instance, this was not a fully mature digital workplace implementation but rather centred on the intranet as a “jumping off point” or “front door”; and it uses self-report rather than actual performance data.
What I found
The model I developed was partially supported (if you’re into statistics, here’s an overview of the results!).
Findings revealed that digital literacy is positively associated with higher effort expectancy. In other words…
Digitally literate employees expect the digital workplace to be easier to use, positively impacting their intention to use it.
However, no relationship was found between digital literacy and performance expectancy. (Effort and performance expectancy are defined respectively as the extent to which an individual believes that system use will be easy and lead to job performance gains.)
Both performance expectancy and effort expectancy positively predicted behavioural intention to continue using the digital workplace. As expected, continuance intention positively predicted performance. I explore these findings, and possible underlying causes, in depth in the paper.
What it means for organisations
The findings suggest that organisations need to consider employees’ digital literacy as part of wider efforts to encourage effective use of digital tools at work. Supporting employees in improving their digital skills may help to reduce their cognitive load and enable them to more easily perform tasks when using the digital workplace.
Organisations need to consider employees’ digital literacy as part of wider efforts to encourage effective use of digital tools at work
Such interventions are critical to support overall organisational digital dexterity across customer experience, operational efficiency, and workforce enablement. Research also suggests that a large proportion of employees expect their organization to help them gain digital skills for work. (See references in paper, e.g. Kasemsap 2018, Ng 2012b, Soule et al. 2016, Kiron et al. 2016).
Findings from my study also suggest rich avenues for future research into the nature of digital literacy at work and its association with digital workplace adoption and use.
Acknowledgements
My deepest thanks go to the people I worked with and who participated at the charitable organisation, and also to the staff who supported me at Coventry University.
In exploring this domain, I was able to draw on some excellent work primarily from the academic sphere, but also within our industry, including:
- Viswanath Venkatesh, distinguished professor and Billingsley Chair in Information Systems at the Walton College of Business, University of Arkansas and driving force behind much influential work on technology acceptance.
- Alexander Van Deursen, Associate professor at the University of Twente, a leading thinker on digital literacy and inclusion.
- Paul Gilster, technology journalist and author of seven books including ‘Digital Literacy’ (1997), who coined the marvelous phrase: “digital literacy is about mastering ideas not keystrokes”.
- In the emergent digital workplace academic research stream, Martin White (Visiting Professor, the Information School, University of Sheffield) and Kristine Dery (Research Scientist) and colleagues at MIT Sloan School of Management.
- And in the industry, the work of thought leaders such as Paul Miller and Digital Workplace Group, and Jane McConnell.
Originally published on Linked In.
